Attorneys/Judges
| Defense(s): | Patrick Reilly | | Judge(s): | Rod Beck |
CONVICTED: Was justice served?
more information on voting
When you vote, you are voting on whether or not the punishment fit the crime, NOT on the severity of the case itself. If you feel the sentence was very weak, you would vote 1 star. If you feel the sentence was very strong, you would vote 5 stars.
Please vote honestly and realistically. These ratings will be used a a tool for many future programs, including a "Peoples Choice" of best and worst sentencing, DA and judge "report cards", and more. Try to resist the temptation to vote 1 star on every case, even if you feel that 100 years in prison isnt enough.
Case #16553 Rating: 1.0 out of 5
Puppy mill - 18 dogs neglected, AKC judges charged
New Tripoli, PA (US)Incident Date: Tuesday, Apr 27, 2010
County: Lehigh
Disposition: Convicted
Defendants/Suspects:
» Miriam Winkler
» James R. Deppen
Case Updates: 1 update(s) available
For more than six hours Tuesday, a Lehigh County district judge heard testimony about fur, feces and urine in an animal cruelty case against well-known dog breeders and American Kennel Club judges Miriam "Mimi" Winkler and James R. Deppen, who ran a kennel in Lynn Township.
After hearing testimony from three veterinarians, a state dog warden and an owner of one of Winkler's championship show dogs, District Judge Rod Beck ordered the case to resume on an unannounced date.
State Dog Warden Orlando Aguirre testified for more than three hours at Beck's Slatington courtroom, where about 20 people attended the summary trial, mostly supporters of Winkler and Deppen.
Aguirre talked about visits to the Judges Choice of Ironwood Kennels, 8383 Allemaengel Road, where he says Winkler and Deppen kept 18 bichons frises with heavily matted coats, a border collie that was extremely malnourished and dehydrated and three Neapolitan mastiffs that needed urgent veterinary care.
Aguirre said he and two other dog wardens went to the kennel on April 27 for an unannounced inspection and discovered the bichons frises with heavily matted hair and living in unsanitary conditions, which he detailed through a series of photos he presented as evidence. He said Winkler gave up the dogs, which she had recently received from other shelters. Aguirre testified she later admitted they were not rescued dogs.
Dr. Alysia Deaven of Jonestown, Lebanon County, testified the heavily matted hair -- a combination of tangled hair, dirt, feces and urine -- would have taken "at least a year" to get that way. "Of the thousand dogs I have seen, these were the worst matted dogs I have seen," she said.
Aguirre said he came back to the kennel on April 28, gave a cease-and-desist order to Winkler and Deppen, and Winkler gave up a sick border collie.
Dr. Korin Mediate of Schuylkill Haven, Schuylkill County, testified the collie was so emaciated, "it is a surprise the body was functioning."
Aguirre said he and the other dog wardens returned on June 4, but neither owner was there. Without a warrant, he entered the kennel and found three Neapolitan mastiffs that needed veterinary care and posted a veterinary-care order at the property. He said he called Winkler to make sure she knew and returned four days later to find one of the mastiffs was dead and left in a wheelbarrow outside the kennel. He testified Winkler tried to pin the dog's death on him.
Dr. Charles Westfield, a defense witness, said he has treated 10 to 15 of Winkler and Deppen's dogs. He said the mastiff that died was 7 1/2 years old, considered old for a mastiff, and that Winkler said she was allowing the dog to live out its life. Westfield testified none of the dogs appeared to have been abused or neglected and only one animal appeared to need immediate veterinary care.
Attorney Patrick Reilly, who represents the kennel owners, accused Aguirre of making sexual advances toward Winkler, but Beck cut him off, saying that wasn't what the hearing was about.
Winkler, 71, and Deppen, 46, both of New Tripoli, each is charged with 22 counts of animal cruelty and one count of conspiracy. They are filing papers in Harrisburg to close the kennel.
Case UpdatesA district judge Wednesday found Lynn Township dog breeders and American Kennel Club judges Miriam "Mimi" Winkler and James R. Deppen not guilty of several cruelty charges against them, but found them guilty of others that may affect their standing as judges.
Winkler and Deppen faced a combined 60 counts of animal cruelty, kennel violations and operating an unlicensed kennel, Judges Choice of Ironwood Kennels at 8383 Allemaengel Road.
District Judge Rod Beck found Winkler, 71, and Deppen, 46, guilty of three cruelty counts against bichons frises, one cruelty count against a border collie and one count of operating an unlicensed kennel. Winkler was also found guilty of making a false statement to a dog warden.
A criminal conspiracy count against them was dismissed and Beck found Winkler and Deppen not guilty of the remaining charges, which included kennel violations and cruelty counts against other bichons frises and Neapolitan mastiffs at the kennel.
Their attorney, Patrick Reilly, says he was shocked by the judge's ruling and plans to appeal. He said he also plans to file a complaint against one of the dog wardens who he said repeatedly lied.
Each guilty count will result in a $200 fine, but they are much more damaging to his clients' reputation, he said. Reilly said one cruelty count is "as bad as 100" for American Kennel Club judges and can affect a judge's standing for a decade.
Beck heard testimony Wednesday from Deppen, who demonstrated how easily a bichon frise's hair can get dirty from simply walking on gravel. He also showed photos of the clean, state-of-the-art kennel.
Dog wardens said it wasn't that way on April 27 when they found 18 bichons frises with heavily matted hair living in unsanitary conditions. Winkler surrendered the dogs to them. The next day, the wardens came back and took a sick border collie and, a week later, they returned and found three Neapolitan mastiffs that needed veterinary care, they said. One of the mastiffs later died.
Defense witnesses included people who know Winkler and Deppen from the dog show circuit, and many who have been to the kennel. They testified the kennel was clean and the dogs there may have needed a haircut and bath, which is typical for long-haired dogs like the bichon frise.
Prosecution witnesses included veterinarians, bichon frise experts and the three dog wardens who said the dogs needed veterinary attention, not grooming.
During closing arguments, Reilly called state dog warden Orlando Aguirre, who headed the investigation and testified for the majority of the first day of the trial, "a stranger to the truth."
"We've wasted 2 1/2 days of the court's time on dogs having a bad hair day," he said.
Lehigh County Deputy District Attorney Jay Jenkins said it's a fact that dogs get dirty, but argued that if owners allow it to continue, it can lead to serious health risks for the animals.
According to testimony, Winkler and Deppen's dogs have been named champions in hundreds of competitions, including the Westminster Kennel Club dog show in New York City and the Crufts Championship Show in England.
Her dogs are owned by celebrities such as actor James Gandolfini, Yankees manager Joe Girardi and singers Harry Connick Jr. and Diana Ross. | Source: The Morning Call - Sept 29, 2010
Update posted on Oct 3, 2010 - 3:32PM |
References |
