Case Snapshot
Case ID: 18579
Classification: Hoarding
Animal: cat
More cases in Jackson County, WI
More cases in WI
Child or elder neglect
Login to Watch this Case

New features are coming soon. Login with Facebook to get an early start and help us test them out!

Prosecutor(s): Gerald Fox
Defense(s): John Bachman
Judge(s): Mark L. Goodman

For more information about the Interactive Animal Cruelty Maps, see the map notes.

Thursday, Jun 3, 2010

County: Jackson

Disposition: Convicted

» Gabriella Bernabei
» Robert J.A. Grassi

Case Updates: 2 update(s) available

A Jackson county couple is accused of keeping at least 100 dead cats in a freezer that didn't work. Now, they say they're being targeted because of their religion.

Gabriella Bernabei says she kept the cats in the freezer because she hadn't found the right time to bury the cats. She says she's Wiccan and in her religion you honor the animal by returning it to Mother Earth. She believes it's her Wiccan beliefs that got her in trouble with the law. But, the sheriff says she and her boyfriend were mistreating their cats.

It was in an un-working freezer in the back of a garage that the Jackson County Sheriff's Department says it found 100 dead cats accumulated over a year and half. The woman who put them there says that number is closer to 50 and says the freezer was working. Bernabei says she brought some of the cats with her from Illinois when her family moved to Jackson County. She says others weren't necessarily theirs, but every animal deserves a burial and she was just waiting for the right moment to return them to the earth.

"That's what you do with a dead animal waiting for a burial. (It was) just proper storage until then. That was responsible," says Bernabei.

Bernabei and her boyfriend Robert Grassi are accused of mistreating animals and not meeting cat sanitation standards.

"The unkempt house and the combination of the fecal matter from the animals with other contributing factors did not make the conditions of the home livable," says Jackson County Sheriff Duane Waldera.

A couple weeks ago, social services removed the couple's three children and placarded the home.

"It's unfortunate that children have to live in a situation like that. But, that's why we have so many agencies - the sheriff's office as well as health and human services. It's too bad that it has to come to that but that's what we're here for - to protect the children," Waldera says.

Seventeen cats were taken to the Jackson County Animal Shelter.

"We don't want anybody to let an animal be in harm's way and these were obviously cats that had been in harm's way for a length of time," says Barb Pfaff, Jackson County's animal control officer.

Pfaff is also in charge of the Jackson County Animal Shelter. She says they're treating the cats for worms and upper respiratory infections. She says some were extremely thin and some couldn't be saved. But, Bernabei says her cats were happy.

"They're part of our family. They're my furry children. We had a connection with them. They have a connection with us and I believe that's the best treatment of all," Bernabei says.

Bernabei says they're also fighting to get their children back. But, she didn't want to talk about the situation without talking with her attorney first. She admits parts of her home were in need of cleaning and says they're taking care of it.

Bernabei and Grassi were not arrested in the case. The sheriff says the department forwarded its report to the district attorney for review and possible charges. He says they're waiting on some test results to determine how the cats died.


On Thursday, June 03, 2010 the Sheriff's Office assisted Jackson County Department of Social Services and the Jackson County Public Health Department at N10377 Samuelson Lane in the Township of Northfield with a home visit and inspection. During the inspection we noticed numerous cats that appeared to be sick and without cleaned litter boxes. On June 3rd, the health officers placarded the residence due to its unsafe health conditions.

Based upon information gathered during the inspection on June 3rd, investigators were able to obtain a search warrant for N10377 Samuelson Lane. During the search, the carcasses of about 100 dead cats were located in a non-functioning freezer located in the garage. Another 17 live cats and kittens were seized by the animal control officer, Barb Pfaff that appeared to be neglected. The dead animals were seized as evidence and the live ones were turned over to the animal shelter.

Gabriella Bernabei and Robert J.A. Grassi were referred to the Jackson County District Attorney's Office for mistreating animals (951.02) and not meeting the cat's sanitation standards (951.14(4).

Case Updates

A Northfield woman who kept more than 100 dead cats in a freezer because she wanted to give them a Wiccan burial has been found guilty of animal mistreatment and child neglect.

However, 46-year-old Gabriella Bernabei said she will attempt to withdraw her pleas made Friday because she said her attorney and the district attorney scared her into an agreement to avoid jail time.

The mother of three maintains her innocence and says she's been unfairly targeted because of her Wiccan beliefs.

"I feel this is an attack on my religion," Bernabei said. "I was told, 'Unless you accept the plea offer, you'll be arrested ... and will spend 10 years in jail.'

"I felt like I had no choice (but to enter into the agreement)."

The pleas came shortly after a jury trial began. Bernabei pleaded no contest to child neglect and entered Alford pleas on four counts of animal mistreatment, which means she does not admit guilt but admits the prosecution could have proven the charges. The court found her guilty on all five charges.

Thirteen counts of animal mistreatment and two counts of child neglect were dismissed but will be considered during sentencing, which has not been set. A hearing for Bernabei to withdraw her pleas is set for Oct. 7, according to defense attorney John Bachman.

The plea agreement had not been filed as of Tuesday, but Bachman said it came with the prosecution's recommendation for up to three months probation and no jail time.

Jackson County District Attorney Gerald Fox could not be reached for comment.

Bernabei said she feels she was poorly represented by Bachman, although Judge Mark L. Goodman denied her request to remove Bachman as counsel.

Bernabei and her husband, Robert J.A. Grassi, 57, were arrested and similarly charged after authorities rescued 17 cats last summer from a home littered with feces and discovered 106 cat carcasses in a nonfunctioning freezer, according to the criminal complaints.

The Jackson County Public Health Department placarded the house due to unhealthy living conditions during a social worker visit June 3, 2010.

The couple's children reportedly were still sleeping when authorities entered the home, and feces was seen on the floor between two of them and on the pillow being used by the other.

The children were placed in a foster home.

Bernabei is free on a $1,000 signature bond and is not allowed to have or care for any cats in her home.

Bernabei said the children " now ages 7, 11 and 12 " are slated to return home.
Source: - Sep 16, 2011
Update posted on Sep 16, 2011 - 11:13PM 
A last-minute plea bargain is reached with a woman found to have about 100 dead cats in her freezer.

A Jackson County jury had already been picked Friday when the plea bargain was reached with Gabriella Bernabei. The Hixton woman was accused of child neglect after deputies found her three children sleeping on the floor, surrounded by cat feces. She was also charged with animal abuse when 17 sick or neglected cats were found.

Part way into her trial Friday, Bernabei pled no contest to child neglect, and conceded there was enough evidence to convict her of four counts of animal abuse.
Source: - Sep 9, 2011
Update posted on Sep 15, 2011 - 7:36PM 


« More cases in Jackson County, WI

Note: Classifications and other fields should not be used to determine what specific charges the suspect is facing or was convicted of - they are for research and statistical purposes only. The case report and subsequent updates outline the specific charges. Charges referenced in the original case report may be modified throughout the course of the investigation or trial, so case updates, when available, should always be considered the most accurate reflection of charges.

For more information regarding classifications and usage of this database, please visit the database notes and disclaimer.