Case Details

Hoarding 20 cats, 7 dogs
Liverpool, OH (US)

Incident Date: Sunday, Jun 4, 2006
County: Columbiana
Local Map: available
Disposition: Alleged
Case Images: 3 files available

Alleged: Wayne Hickman

Case Updates: 3 update(s) available

Case ID: 8840
Classification: Hoarding, Neglect / Abandonment
Animal: cat, dog (non pit-bull)
View more cases in OH (US)
Login to Watch this Case

A total of 28 animal cruelty charges were filed in Municipal Court on June 6 against an Erie Street, East End man.

Columbiana County Humane Society Officer Joseph Rayl said each charge represents cruelty to one animal.

Rayl explained that he received a telephone call about conditions at 1303 Erie St. two days before, but was unable to respond until Sunday.

When he arrived at the home, he was met by the landlord. He said they went to the back of the house where there are sliding glass doors, and could see inside the living room and into the kitchen.

The landlord told Rayl he had been inside once, but he would not go back in. He told Rayl he would stand outside beside the doors.

Looking inside, Rayl said he could see animal feces everywhere. One dog, a white puppy, was lying in the mess. Other puppies were jumping on it, and it never moved. Rayl said he could see it was breathing, but that it was wheezing and apparently fighting for its life.

While Rayl was deciding whether to enter, Brenda Austin of the Humane Society arrived. It was then determined they should remove the animal, and the plan at that time was to remove only that one.

However, after entering the home and searching the premises, it was determined all of the animals needed to be removed for their safety.

The white puppy was placed in a carrier and taken out to get fresh air. It only lived about a half hour longer.

Rayl said the odor was so strong, they used Vapor-rub both inside and underneath their noses. Breathing masks were donned.

"You couldn't see the floor, feces was caked in piles everywhere. Garbage bags were filled with it," said Rayl, who added that he believes there may have been some dead animals in one or more of the garbage bags.

Conditions in the upstairs were just as bad. This was where they found the cats. They had found five other puppies and the mother downstairs. A black poodle also had been in the house, but the landlord said when he had opened the door the day before, the black poodle ran out. No one was sure where it went.

The cats, which were shut in a room so they could not get in or out, were given drinks of water. There appeared to be no food or water anywhere in any of the rooms.

Several other members of the Humane Society arrived with carriers. Rayl said two more animals were judged to be quite ill. The animals were mangy and had skin sores.

The animals were taken to various locations. Rayl said Humane Society personnel know where they are. He just knew they had been taken to homes, and that some may have been taken to a veterinary service for examinations.

A description of the renter of the property had been given to Rayl, along with a description of his car. While they were removing the animals, he observed a car approaching and said it fit the description.

A neighbor then stated, "There he is."

Rayl shouted for the driver to stop, but though he slowed, he continued past the house and drove away. Rayl said he was not sure if the man heard him or not. Rayl then got into the Humane Society truck and attempted to catch the man, but lost him.

This was the first major case for Rayl since being named humane officer May 1.

Rayl said he had to remove two pit bulls from homes in East Liverpool , but he never expected to have a case such as he was in charge of Sunday.

Austin of the Humane Society said she does not recall handling anything this severe before. She said that the floors were so dirty with animal waste that they were slippery, and she could hear her shoes "squishing" as she walked.

Another member of the Humane Society said she has four of the cats at her home, and she said she has never seen animals so mistreated. She has been a volunteer with the Society six months, but in that time, has never seen anything near this case.

The name of the owner of the animals will be released today when court charges have been filed.

Case Updates

An area man blames the Columbiana County Humane Society for the condition of some 29 animals found living in uninhabitable conditions at an East End residence last week.

A man claiming to be Wayne Hickman, 34, formerly of Erie Street, contacted The Review via e-mail Thursday to plead his case against what he calls "misinformation and lies" spread against him by the Columbiana County Human Society and the media.

In the e-mail, Hickman says he contacted the Humane Society about a month prior to the organization's June 8 rescue of the animals in his Erie Street home.

"About a month prior to the Humane Society coming to Erie Street, my wife called them for help," he wrote. "She left a message crying, telling them our house was being overrun by our animals and we needed help. She left her name and phone number...They have yet to return the call. I called twice after getting voice mail and the box was too full to leave another message."

Bethany Drosendahl, Executive Director at the Humane Society, said no such call was ever received at the institution.

"We keep a phone log and we have a 24 to 48 hour return policy," she said. "We also have a shelter coordinator who is very conscientious about her duties. There was never a call."

"Besides, if they have all of those animals, they are responsible for the situation that they created there," Drosendahl continued. "There are plenty of ways for people to help themselves in any situation."

She said there were only two days ever that the voice mail box at the Humane Society was full while officials were busy with another agency obligation.

Hickman, who admitted all of the animals were either strays or offspring of strays, said he also attempted to made arrangements with the Columbiana County dog pound and Angels for Animals for help. However, money troubles and no vacancies kept him hoarding some 30 animals in his home.

He stated he made a number of attempts to clean his Erie Street home, but he could not keep it clean because of such a large number of dogs and cats inhabiting the residence.

"Several attempts were made to clean, but as they should have seen, there were shredded garbage bags everywhere," he said. "I would spend an entire day cleaning only to have it spread everywhere when I was finished."

Drosendahl said that conditions in the house suggested little or no cleaning attempts made by the owner.

"It was a long-term pervasive problem," she said. "And think about it. When I go and clean my house, I go and bundle up my trash in a trash can. If you go into any good shelter, they have a lot of animals and it's still clean."

The court documents filed at East Liverpool Municipal Court indicate Hickman is being charged with depriving an animal of "necessary sustenance or impound" or confining "an animal without supplying it during such confinement with sufficient quantity of good wholesome food and water."

Hickman responded to that allegation, indicating he was sure to provide food and water to the animals daily.

"Not one day passed without them being fed premium cat and dog food with fresh water," he wrote. "Anyone who says otherwise is a liar."

Hickman claims he spent an average of $28 a week on premium cat and dog food. He said when humane officers invaded the residence, there was at least 50 pounds of cat food and that he was bringing a 40 pound bag of dog food to the residence that day.

Neighbors reported previously that while humane officers were working to rescue the animals at the residence, Hickman returned home, and, fled upon seeing the officials.

"To be honest, all of that is in the past and isn't really relevant now," said Drosendahl. "If he thinks he's innocent, that's what trials are for. If he's innocent, he should go through and prove that he's innocent. Go ahead and step forward."

On June 4, Humane Society officials invaded Hickman's rented Erie Street residence and collected a number of animals living in reported unliveable conditions. One dog taken from the residence died just 30 minutes after it was recovered. At least two other animals were found in "bad condition," their skin reportedly covered in feces and sores and 14 cats were found locked in a small room in the upstairs portion of the house.

Charges were filed against Hickman that week and a warrant has since been issued for his arrest on 29 counts of animal cruelty.
Source: The Times-Leader - June 16, 2006
Update posted on Jun 16, 2006 - 12:22PM 
Charges have been filed against the man accused of abandoning some 30 animals at an East End home for days.

Columbiana County Humane Society Humane Officer Joseph Rayl appeared in East Liverpool Municipal Court Tuesday and filed papers for some 29 counts of animal cruelty against Wayne Hickman, 34, of Erie Street. A warrant has since been issued for Hickman's arrest. Each of the charges represent cruelty to one animal.

According to court documents, Hickman is being charged with depriving "an animal of necessary sustenance or impound" or confining "an animal without supplying it during such confinement with a sufficient quantity of good wholesome food and water."

Humane society employees rescued a majority of the animals from an East End home Sunday after receiving a call about the residence's conditions two days before.

Rayl said Monday the floors were covered in animal feces and at least one dog was found wheezing and gasping for its life. That dog died 30 minutes after it was found. Two other animals were found in bad condition, their skin caked with feces and sores, and at least 14 cats were found locked in a small room in the upstairs of the Erie Street residence.

Neighbors reported seeing Hickman return while Humane Society employees were working to rescue the animals. Rayl said Monday the East End man fled when he saw employees surrounding the residence. The Humane Society Officer's attempt to catch Hickman failed.

Some animals were rushed to veterinary clinics for treatment while others were housed safely until responsible owners can be found.
Source: Times-Leader - June 9, 2006
Update posted on Jun 15, 2006 - 9:41AM 
An East Liverpool man remains on the run. He's facing 28 counts of animal cruelty, one for each animal inside his home.

Sunday night, police found more than 28 animals locked in a home on Erie Street in East Liverpool.

According to the Humane Society, while the agency was searching the home the resident returned, but he didn't stay long.

Officials said that when he saw his home being search, he took off. Police tried to locate the animal owner but never found him.

According to officials, animal feces, cat urine and garbage covered the floors of every room in the suspect's home. One dog was dead when authorities arrived and two other dogs had to be euthanized because of their poor condition.

NEWS9 has learned the suspect in this case is a probation violator.
Source: WTOV - June 5, 2006
Update posted on Jun 7, 2006 - 6:15PM 

Neighborhood Map

For more information about the Interactive Animal Cruelty Maps, see the map notes.

Back to Top

Add this case to:   Del.icio.us | Digg | Furl Furl |

References

WTOV9  - June 4, 2006
The Review
WTOV - June 5, 2006

« OH State Animal Cruelty Map

Add to GoogleNot sure what these icons mean? Click here.

Note: Classifications and other fields should not be used to determine what specific charges the suspect is facing or was convicted of - they are for research and statistical purposes only. The case report and subsequent updates outline the specific charges. Charges referenced in the original case report may be modified throughout the course of the investigation or trial, so case updates, when available, should always be considered the most accurate reflection of charges.

For more information regarding classifications and usage of this database, please visit the database notes and disclaimer.



Send this page to a friend
© Copyright 2001-2007 Pet-Abuse.Com. All rights reserved. Site Map ¤ Disclaimer ¤ Privacy Policy