CONVICTED: Was justice served?
more information on voting
When you vote, you are voting on whether or not the punishment fit the crime, NOT on the severity of the case itself. If you feel the sentence was very weak, you would vote 1 star. If you feel the sentence was very strong, you would vote 5 stars.
Please vote honestly and realistically. These ratings will be used a a tool for many future programs, including a "People’s Choice" of best and worst sentencing, DA and judge "report cards", and more. Try to resist the temptation to vote 1 star on every case, even if you feel that 100 years in prison isn’t enough.
Case #2958 Rating: 3.6 out of 5
Horse neglect
Holstein, NE (US)Incident Date: Wednesday, Oct 1, 2003
County: Adams
Disposition: Convicted
Defendant/Suspect: Rose Marie Arthur
Case Updates: 4 update(s) available
The woman convicted in September of 17 of 19 counts of animal cruelty in Adams County Court for neglecting her horses will spend more than five months in jail.
Rose Marie Arthur, 42, was sentenced on the animal cruelty charges as well as not having the animal health certificates to transport her 19 horses from Kansas to Nebraska.
Prosecutors said the horses were found starving and near death at a ranch near Holstein in January. The neglect allegedly occurred from Oct. 1, 2003, through Jan. 29.
Authorities had said the animals likely were being fed daily, but the weren't being fed enough.
Arthur was also ordered to pay $453 a month for five years in restitution to the county, which has been taking care of the horses.
Case UpdatesAdams County will soon sell a group of horses that have cost the county more than $77,000 since 2004.
The animals were confiscated in an animal neglect case. They will be sold at a public auction in April.
The horses were originally owned by Rose Marie Arthur, 44, who was convicted on 17 of 19 counts of neglect and 19 counts of lacking health certificates.
Arthur was sentenced to jail and ordered to pay restitution. She appealed and Adams County District Judge Stephen Illingworth upheld the decision, but lowered the restitution based on Arthur's ability to pay. Illingworth ruled the horses could not be sold until the appeals were finished.
The county filed a lien against the horses in 2004 to recoup the cost of caring for the horses. Each horse costs $4 per day for food and lodging, not including veterinary costs.
Originally, the county took 19 horses into custody. One colt was born and three horses were released, leaving 17 in county care. Four of the horses had to be euthanized during the appeals, leaving 13 to be sold.
"It added up to an enormous amount," said Adams County Sheriff Gregg Magee. "It's the relief many have been looking for."
Adams County Attorney Donna Fegler Daiss said the court ordered the horses to be sold at a public auction to pay for the maintenance costs.
Arthur also was ordered by the court to provide any breeding documentation that could increase the value of the horses. The money will go to pay off expenses incurred by the county first, she said. Anything remaining would go back to Arthur. | Source: Beatrice Daily Sun - March 25, 2007
Update posted on Mar 25, 2007 - 6:23PM |
Horses confiscated in an animal neglect case two years ago will be sold by the Adams County Sheriff's Department.
The animals have cost the county more than $71,500.
Adams County District Judge Stephen Illingworth ruled that the Sheriff's Office can foreclose on a lien on 17 horses formerly owned by Rose Marie Arthur, 44.
Sheriff's deputies originally took Arthur's horses into custody in January 2004 when she was charged with 19 counts of neglect and of lacking health certificates.
The county filed a lien against the horses in 2004 to recoup the cost of caring for the horses. Each horse costs $4 per day for food and lodging, not including veterinary costs.
Adams County Attorney Donna Fegler Daiss said the court ordered the horses to be sold at a public auction to pay for the maintenance costs.
Arthur also was ordered by the court to provide any breeding documentation that could increase the value of the horses. The money will go to pay off expenses incurred by the county first, she said. Anything remaining would go back to Arthur.
She said the Adams County Sheriffs Office will arrange the sale in November if an appeal is not filed by Arthur in the civil case. | Source: Journal Star - Oct 22, 2006
Update posted on Oct 23, 2006 - 6:28AM |
Horses held as evidence in an animal cruelty case in Adams County can enter foster care to help control the county's expenses.
The 17 horses have been in the county's custody since 2004, after owner Rose Marie Arthur was convicted of 17 counts of cruel neglect and 19 counts of failing to obtain health certificates for the horses.
The horses' care has been costly: $49,970 for daily, routine care and $3,121 in veterinarian bills, said Adams County Sheriff Gregg Magee.
The foster care will cut the burden on the county, Magee said, but the county will retain custody until the case is resolved.
Donna Fegler Daiss, county attorney, said the county Board of Supervisors has been interested in the foster care option.
"These are just individuals willing to take care of the horses for us," she said. "We're still responsible for medical care; we're just not responsible with regard to food and shelter."
Foster homes for the horses won't be limited to people in Adams County, Magee said, but distance is a factor, because his office will need to check on them.
Magee said his office had many calls from people interested in adopting the horses, and he hopes that some will consider foster care instead.
After the county case against Arthur was resolved, the county took custody of 17 of the horses. Arthur appealed the verdict, but a district judge upheld it and ruled that the horses could not be sold until the appeal process is finished.
Arthur filed an appeal to the Nebraska Court of Appeals in August.
If the conviction is upheld, the horses will be sold at auction, said Fegler Daiss, the county attorney.
She also said the county may agree to reimburse the foster care providers. | Source: Scottsbluff Star Herald - Oct 21, 2005
Update posted on Oct 21, 2005 - 5:59PM |
Adams County has been spending about $40 a day caring for a herd of neglected horses. Now, it wants the woman accused of harming them to reimburse the county for their care or be allowed to sell the horses.
The County Attorney's Office made that request to the district court. It wants the court to either order the woman to post a bond high enough to reimburse the county for the horses' care or issue an order allowing the county to sell the animals.
Rose Marie Arthur was sentenced in November to more than five months in jail for animal cruelty and not having the animal health certificates to transport the 19 horses from Kansas to Nebraska.
Prosecutors said the horses were found starving and near death at a ranch near Holstein in January. The neglect occurred from Oct. 1, 2003, through Jan. 29, prosecutors said.
Arthur was ordered at her sentencing to pay more than $450 a month for five years - totaling $26,295 - to cover the county's expenses. But Adams County Attorney Donna Fegler Daiss says its unlikely Arthur will be able to make the payments.
Arthur told the judge at her sentencing that she was making less than $7 per hour and her husband was unemployed, Fegler Daiss said | Source: Omaha World Herald - Dec 17, 2004
Update posted on Dec 18, 2004 - 8:03PM |
References
« More cases in Adams County, NE
|
