71 dogs seized from breeder
Merville, BC (CA)

Incident Date: Tuesday, Jul 5, 2011

Disposition: Alleged

Alleged: Nancy Kitching

The B.C. SPCA plans to recommend animal cruelty charges against a Vancouver Island woman accused of breeding genetically unhealthy dogs.

The SPCA seized 71 dogs, including 43 puppies, from Green Acres Kennels in Merville last Tuesday, alleging the dogs were in distress and in poor health.

"A significant number of the problems were the result of bad breeding and genetic conditions produced by bad breeding and [the owner] is not taking care of them," said Marcie Moriarty, SPCA manager of cruelty investigations.

Some animals have severe dental decay, including one that will require most, if not all, of its teeth removed.

Several pugs and French bull dogs seized have stenotic nares, or pinched and narrow nostrils, causing difficulty in breathing. Some animals with the condition were found in an unventilated barn in high heat, said Moriarty.

Other health issues include dermatitis, yeast infection, spinal malformation and "swimmer puppy" syndrome, a congenital defect marked by a flat chest and abdomen, which compresses the organs and causes the legs to move in an abnormal paddling motion.

Moriarty said some of the puppies were seized because they were too young to be separated from their mother, but that the veterinarian who examined the animals reported many of them should not be bred because of hereditary defects.

"A good breeder would never breed those dogs," she said. "It's not fair to the dogs and it's the public who suffers when they have to spend thousands of dollars on vet bills."

Owner Nancy Kitching denied the allegations: "That's a bunch of crock," she told The Province. "The dogs are not in distress."

SPCA officers have visited her property twice in recent weeks, she said. She has been trying to comply with the checklist of issues they gave her, but needed more time.

She admitted one Yorkshire Terrier needed dental work, but said she was waiting to sell a dog to afford the vet bill.

She added she has been in the dog breeding business for 18 years and hasn't received a complaint from customers about sick puppies.

On Friday, she surrendered ownership of the animals to the SPCA, citing the high financial cost - up to $60,000 in legal, boarding and veterinarian fees - she'd incur in order to get them back.

She insisted she raised "young, beautiful, healthy, well-bred dogs" and did not run a puppy mill.

But Moriarty said that while the kennel might not have the row of crates and cramped conditions typically associated with a mill, it fits the bill.

"There's definitely a problem here of extremely poor genetics which is causing distress to the animal, and she is repeatedly breeding these dogs."

Kitching said she plans offer laser treatment for dogs with skin problems. She said she still has six dogs and eight puppies so may still "dabble" in breeding.

References

« Back to Search Results

Note: Classifications and other fields should not be used to determine what specific charges the suspect is facing or was convicted of - they are for research and statistical purposes only. The case report and subsequent updates outline the specific charges. Charges referenced in the original case report may be modified throughout the course of the investigation or trial, so case updates, when available, should always be considered the most accurate reflection of charges.

For more information regarding classifications and usage of this database, please visit the database notes and disclaimer.