Case Details
Share:

Case Snapshot
Case ID: 15908
Classification: Neglect / Abandonment
Animal: horse
More cases in Colleton County, SC
More cases in SC
Login to Watch this Case

Attorneys/Judges
Judge(s): Kenneth Campbell, Perry Buckner


Images for this Case



47 malnourished hoses seized from bible camp
Cottageville, SC (US)

Incident Date: Tuesday, May 5, 2009
County: Colleton

Disposition: Alleged
Case Images: 1 files available

Alleged: Eddy Ackerman

Case Updates: 6 update(s) available

Sheriff's deputies, animal control officers and volunteers converged on the Gift Horse Bible Camp near Cottageville Tuesday morning. It didn't take them long to find obvious signs the horses were malnourished. Ribs were sticking out of some of the animals.

The man in charge of the horses says he is not starving them. "No sir, no sir. We feed them everyday. They've been fed everyday since they've been here," said Gift Horse Bible Camp Director Eddie Ackerman.

After getting complaints that the horses looked too thin, they got a judge to sign an order allowing them to take all 46 of them. "I know they look like they've been starved to death, but they haven't been," Ackerman said. "And I have the records of oats that's fed to them to prove that, you know."

Ackerman says he's tried to give the horses hay, oats and vitamins, but they still won't eat. "If you can see a horse with an 800 pound bale of hay in this field and and he's that thin and he can't go over there and eat, then something's wrong." Investigators are trying to find out exactly what's wrong. They are leaving no stone unturned, taking blood samples and testing the horses' drinking water.

Colleton County authorities say they don't have enough room to hold all of the horses, so they will keep six. The other 40 will be sent to Charleston. Ultimately it will be up to a judge to decide who gets custody of the animals.

"This thing right here is either going to make this ministry what we have started to do or it's gonna end it," Ackerman said. "It's not up to me. It's up to God and the people that see what's going on."

A hearing has been scheduled for May 12th to decide who gets custody of the horses.


Case Updates

Heavily sedated, Shaker the saddle horse dozed on his side as veterinary surgeon John Malark went to work on a damaged left eye that had gone untreated for months. The injury, caused by the metal end of a water hose, was just too severe. The eye had to come out.

It was just one more indignity for the strong stallion.

Shaker was of one 47 horses seized last May from a Colleton County Bible camp after neighbors complained that the animals were being abused and neglected. Animal control workers said they found a host of undernourished horses. The rib cages of several could be clearly seen through their skin.

After months of legal wrangling, county authorities got the go-ahead last month to put the horses up for adoption, Tim Lynes, director of Colleton County Animal Control, said. About 30 of the original pool are still awaiting permanent homes. So far, the county has spent close to $120,000 on the horses' care, though donations have helped offset the cost to taxpayers, he said.

"They're in very good shape," Lynes said. "They're all looking great."

Shaker and 12 other horses were adopted by the Livestock Equine Awareness and Rescue Network, which moved them to a farm in Meggett while searching for permanent owners and "forever" homes for the animals. LEARN depends on donations to feed, shelter and care for its horses, and the effort is straining the group's budget, founder Elizabeth Steed said.

The group took in the horses that had the most severe special needs. None were vaccinated; all were underweight and ridden with parasites, Steed said. The group has spent more than $12,000 caring for the horses, she said.

"At first, everyone who heard about it wanted to donate," she said. "But as time passes, people forget about it. But the horses keep eating and needing veterinary care."

Malark, who runs Edisto Equine Clinic on Yonge's Island, has provided medical care for the rescued horses at a discount, as has Summerville veterinarian Mark Shambley, Steed said. Still, bills are mounting. Even at a discounted rate, Shaker's eye operation and gelding ran around $1,000, she said. "It's intricate surgery," Steed said. "And it's expensive."

Shaker's former owner, Eddy Ackerman, faces 43 counts of animal cruelty in connection with the case. Ackerman runs Gift Horse Bible Camp near Cottageville, where the horses -- along with a dozen dogs and some chickens -- were seized by animal control officers May 5. Ackerman argued that some of the horses weren't eating because they were sick but that none was abused or neglected.

Though the courts have ruled against him, Ackerman still wants to reclaim the animals, Lynes said. Ackerman could not be reached for comment last week.

The seizure was one the largest in state history, second only to a 2003 raid in Lexington that netted 50 horses, said B.B. Weavil, regional director for the South Carolina Horsemen's Council. That group is still held up in a legal quagmire, straining finances as its numbers have grown to 80 horses, thanks to new offspring, she said.

Weavil commended Colleton County with persevering in its legal battle and paving the way for adoptions.

At the same time, the demand on animal rescue groups appears increasing across the state as they deal with more and more unwanted or improperly cared for horses, Weavil said. Many people simply take on more than they can handle when they buy a horse and don't realize the level of care that it requires. The sour economy isn't helping matters either, she said.

"It's a growing problem," she said. "Not only are people walking away from them, but there is shortage of buyers out there."

The council has launched a survey to gauge how bad the problem is, but some estimates put the number of unwanted horses at more than 1,000 across the state. One national survey estimated there are about 170,000 unwanted horses across the country. Finding new homes for them can be a problem. "It's much harder to adopt out a horse than it is a dog or a cat," LEARN volunteer Leslie Tumbleston said.

Lynes said the applications keep coming in for a chance at adopting the Cottageville horses for $150 apiece. The county is allowing a maximum of two horses per person to prevent the same situation from happening again.

Of the original 13 horses LEARN adopted, six remained at week's end, Steed said. A local woman adopted Shaker and three other horses Thursday, with hopes of retraining them for a 4-H program. Steed hasn't put a price on adoptions for LEARN's horses, just whatever anyone can donate to give the horses a good home. "It's more important to me to get them a forever home than it is to get more money," she said.
Source: USA Today News - January 31, 2010
Update posted on Jan 31, 2010 - 10:10PM 
The horses seized from a Bible camp after neighbors complained they were being abused are gradually finding new homes, but another legal challenge has put adoptions on hold again.

As of Friday, 19 of the 47 horses had been adopted, Colleton County Animal Control Director Tim Lynes said.

One of the animals had to be put down, he said. He's still hoping to find homes for the 27 remaining animals.

"We still need help, both with adoption and with feeding them," Lynes said.

He was preparing to move some of the stallions from the shelter to a ranch for gelding Friday when he got a notice that Eddy Ackerman, who runs the Bible camp, had filed another legal challenge. A judge will hear arguments Tuesday morning. Adoptions are on hold again until after the hearing.

"We will still continue to take applications," Lynes said. "I hope this is resolved Tuesday."

Animal control officers took the horses -- along with a dozen dogs and some chickens -- on May 5 from Gift Horse Bible Camp near Cottageville after reports they were being neglected and abused. Ackerman argued that some of the horses weren't eating because they were sick but that none was abused or neglected.

Magistrate Kenneth Campbell ruled in favor of the county in June. Ackerman appealed, and Circuit Judge Perry Buckner upheld Campbell's ruling.

Ackerman also faces a jury trial on 43 charges of animal cruelty. The maximum penalty for each offense is $500 and 60 days in jail. A date for that trial has not yet been set.

The county filed the animal cruelty charges to try to recoup some of the money spent nursing the horses back to health and feeding them, Lynes said. The county has spent more than $50,000 taking care of the horses.

The county has been caring for 14 stallions at the shelter on Poor Farm Road. The rest of the horses have been at J Bar Farms in Meggett, which is affiliated with the Livestock Equine Awareness and Rescue Network. The county has been paying all the bills, Lynes said.

People wanting to adopt horses have to demonstrate they are able to take care of them and pass a background check, Lynes said.
Source: Post and Courier - Nov 2, 2009
Update posted on Nov 2, 2009 - 12:22AM 
A herd of horses seized from a Colleton County Bible camp are still up for adoption after another round in court Tuesday.

Colleton County Magistrate John McLeod rejected more appeals from the former owner to get the 47 horses back.

Animal-control officers took the horses May 5 from Gift Horse Bible Camp near Cottageville after reports they were being neglected and abused.

Eddy Ackerman, who runs the camp, argued that some of the horses weren't eating because they were sick, but none was abused or neglected.

Ackerman is not giving up. He filed an appeal with the S.C. Supreme Court on Monday.

The custody battle is over as far as Animal Control Director Tim Lynes is concerned. Lynes said he does not expect the Supreme Court even to hear Ackerman's appeal, especially since he's representing himself.

Meanwhile, Lynes is taking applications from people who want to adopt a horse. Adoption would cost about $150, Lynes said. The new owner must also pass a background check and demonstrate he or she has the space and money to take care of the animal.

Lynes is taking care of 14 stallions at the animal shelter on Poor Farm Road. The rest of the horses are at the Livestock Equine Awareness and Rescue Network's J Bar Farms ranch in Meggett.

The county has spent more than $60,000 so far nursing the horses back to health and feeding them, Lynes said. He said he had to get involved when he saw the condition of the horses.

"I don't regret it," he said.

The county has received about $5,000 in donations to care for the horses but could use more help, Lynes said.

Lynes hopes to recoup some of the cost in a criminal trial on 43 charges of animal cruelty. The maximum penalty for each offense is $500 and 60 days in jail.

The jury trial is set for the last week of October, Lynes said.
Source: Post and Courier - Sept 16, 2009
Update posted on Nov 2, 2009 - 12:22AM 
Officials begin the task of finding homes for horses seized in a Colleton County animal cruelty case.

A judge has turned down an appeal from the owner of over 40 horses that officials ruled were being mistreated. Eddy Ackerman, who had the horses at a camp near the Colleton County town of Cottageville, made the appeal. The ruling paves the way for Colleton County to work toward finding homes for the horses.

On May 5, officers working on behalf of Colleton County Animal Control seized a dozen dogs, and a number of chickens, along with the horses from the Gift Horse Bible Camp after reports that the animals were suffering from neglect. Ackerman says some of the horses were not eating because they were sick, not because they were abused. Ackerman has asked that the charges of animal cruelty be dismissed.
Source: South Carolina Radio Network - Aug 12, 2009
Update posted on Nov 2, 2009 - 12:20AM 
A Bible camp owner is demanding a jury trial to fight 43 charges of animal cruelty after Colleton County animal-control officers seized horses the county said were underfed and abused.

Gift Horse Bible Camp Owner Eddy Ackerman of Cottageville appeared at a hearing this week. Magistrate John McLeod granted his request for a jury trial on the animal-cruelty charges. A date has not been set.

Ackerman also is appealing a previous ruling that the county should keep the horses.

Ackerman said the horses were skinny because they had worms that were resistant to the pills he was giving them. He said he called the county for advice and was using medicine a county veterinarian had recommended. He contends neighbors who didn't like the horses pressured county officials to find a reason to take them.

"To my way of thinking, it's absolutely ludicrous to say it's illegal to have a sick horse," Ackerman said Wednesday. "That would be like saying it's illegal for parents to have sick children."

Animal-control officers said they found moldy oats on the ground and algae-filled water in the buckets when they seized the horses May 5. Ackerman disputed the report.

The county has spent about $49,000 nursing the horses back to health and feeding them, Animal Control Director Tim Lynes said. Each horse has gained about 150 pounds under the county's care, he said.

The county has been caring for 14 horses at the shelter on Poor Farm Road. The Livestock Equine Awareness and Rescue Network is caring for the rest of them. The county has been paying all the food bills, Lynes said.

The county won't put the horses up for adoption until after Ackerman's appeal, Lynes said. The maximum penalty for each offense is $500 and 60 days in jail. He's looking for help caring for them in the meantime.

Ackerman said the animals would be fine eating grass at the camp, as they have for the last 40 years.
Previous story

Seized horses stay with county, published 05/29/09

"They were created to eat grass," Ackerman said. "They don't have to have all the other stuff that people feed them. We've got grass growing out here knee-high because the horses aren't out here to eat it."

He said he's fighting to get the horses back because he uses them to work with boys who don't have fathers.
Source: Post and Courier - July 16, 2009
Update posted on Nov 2, 2009 - 12:19AM 
Nearly four dozen undernourished horses seized from a Colleton County Bible camp earlier this month will remain in custody of the county, a magistrate ruled Thursday.

Animal-control officers took 47 horses on May 5 from Gift Horse Bible Camp near Cottageville after receiving reports they were being neglected and abused.

Eddy Ackerman, who runs the camp, argued that some of the horses weren't eating because they were sick, but said he never neglected them.

Magistrate Kenneth Campbell disagreed and ordered all the horses to remain with the county.

Ackerman said he will fight to get his animals back because he uses them to work with boys who don't have fathers.

"This is a David and Goliath issue," he said. "I'll definitely have a lawyer next time."

Ackerman relies on donations to feed the animals. He acknowledged that the horses were thin but said they were healthy until recently, and he thought the county was coming out to help him figure out how to heal them. He said the county took his horses because complaining neighbors pressured officials.

Now, it's the county that's looking for contributions to help pay for horse feed.

The county can't put the horses up for adoption until after Ackerman's appeal, Animal Control Director Tim Lynes said. Meanwhile, he expects to spend about $18,000 on food and medical care this first month.

"It wiped out my budget," he said. "We're looking for donations."

Livestock Equine Awareness and Rescue Network founder Elizabeth Steed, who has been caring for 30 of the horses, hailed the ruling.

"We're just ecstatic," she said. "We just feel like the horses won today."

Steed said she's been feeding the horses a special diet to get their weight back up, and they were so wild she doesn't see how anyone could have ridden them.

Officials are seeing more cases of owners neglecting horses as the economy makes it harder to feed them, Lynes said.

"Right now I'm working five other cases," he said. "I think the economy has egged this on quite a bit."

No charges have been filed against Ackerman.
Source: Post and Courier - May 29, 2009
Update posted on Nov 2, 2009 - 12:18AM 

References

  • « SC State Animal Cruelty Map
    « More cases in Colleton County, SC

    Add to GoogleNot sure what these icons mean? Click here.

    Note: Classifications and other fields should not be used to determine what specific charges the suspect is facing or was convicted of - they are for research and statistical purposes only. The case report and subsequent updates outline the specific charges. Charges referenced in the original case report may be modified throughout the course of the investigation or trial, so case updates, when available, should always be considered the most accurate reflection of charges.

    For more information regarding classifications and usage of this database, please visit the database notes and disclaimer.



    Send this page to a friend
© Copyright 2001-2010 Pet-Abuse.Com. All rights reserved. Site Map ¤ Disclaimer ¤ Privacy Policy