Case Snapshot
Case ID: 15335
Classification: Neglect / Abandonment
Animal: horse
More cases in Waynesboro City County, VA
More cases in VA
Person(s) in animal care
« Back to Search Results
Login to Watch this Case

New features are coming soon. Login with Facebook to get an early start and help us test them out!


Attorneys/Judges
Judge(s): William Heatwole


For more information about the Interactive Animal Cruelty Maps, see the map notes.



Thursday, Mar 5, 2009

County: Waynesboro City

Charges: Misdemeanor
Disposition: Convicted

Defendant/Suspect: Tory Allen Garrett

Case Updates: 5 update(s) available

The owner of a Waynesboro farm faces a cruelty charge related to the apparent starving death of one of his horses.

A state veterinarian says emaciation and parasites killed the horse earlier this month. A woman reportedly bought the animal from 53-year-old Tory Allen Garrett. She says she took it straight to her vet, but it had to be put down.

Waynesboro police say they've been called to the Garrett farm before, but did not find evidence of criminal neglect. According to Sergeant Kelly Walker with the Waynesboro Police Department, "This past year there was a horse that had died on the property. We've been involved in previous complaints...investigating them about the care of horses on that property."

Neighbors claim to have seen Garrett's other horses appeared malnourished, sometimes even unable to stand on their own. Garrett says he routinely buys neglected horses and tries nurses them back to health.


Case Updates

An Afton man convicted of animal cruelty in a case that saw 41 horses, ponies and donkeys seized from his property last year was spared jail time at a sentencing hearing Monday afternoon in Waynesboro Circuit Court.

Tory A. Garrett, 54, was convicted in March on two misdemeanor counts of animal cruelty. Ten additional charges were taken under advisement. Circuit Judge Humes J. Franklin Jr. ordered Garrett to pay $7,939 to the Augusta Regional SPCA and $3,717 to the city of Waynesboro for costs incurred in the seizing and subsequent care of the animals.

Garrett faced the possibility of two years in jail.

The investigation against Garrett was launched in March 2009 after he sold an emaciated pony to a Staunton woman, according to previous evidence. The pony suffered from parasites and malnutrition, and was euthanized. A second pony died following the seizure.

At the March 10 trial, Waynesboro Animal Control Officer Dee Price testified that many of Garrett's animals appeared unstable and underweight.

Two witnesses testified a dead bird was found in a water trough for the horses. Evidence also showed low-grade hay was found on Garrett's property.

Echoing claims made at the trial, on Monday defense attorney Dana Cormier continued to blame the investigation on the Staunton woman who bought the pony, claiming she targeted Garrett to get out of paying for the sick animal. Cormier said Garrett initially rebuffed several offers from the woman because "he thought the horse needed to be put down."

Waynesboro assistant prosecutor David Ledbetter, who sought a month in jail for Garrett, said, "These ponies were starved to death."

Franklin is allowing Garrett, a drywaller by trade, five years to pay the restitution. Garrett cannot own or care for any horses until the restitution is paid in full.

Following the hearing, Debbie Caywood, director of the Augusta Regional SPCA, said didn't dispute the judge's decision, but said jail time in animal cruelty cases needs to be considered in future cases to prevent the starvation and neglect of animals.

"Maybe that's what's going to have to occur," she said.

Caywood said 39 of the animals and two colts that were born after the March 2009 seizure have found homes.

Officer Price, who noted she favored a jail sentence for Garrett, said the financial strain of owning the animals apparently became too much for the defendant to handle.

"He just lost grip on what he was doing," she said.

Annie Delp, director of Eagle Hill Farm, an equine rescue organization in Fredericksburg, said there are about 10 rescue groups in Virginia that horse owners can turn to when feeling the financial pinch of caring for the animals. Delp said it's an ongoing issue that has grown worse with a stagnating economy.

"Most rescues are basically full," she said. "It's epidemic."

Delp said many horse owners usually wait too long to seek help.

"The problem is, it takes a horse 40 days to look as skinny as a rail, and three to four months to recover," she said.
Source: News-Leader.com - May 4, 2010
Update posted on Jun 2, 2010 - 5:23PM 
An Afton man convicted of animal cruelty faces up to two years in jail.

Waynesboro Circuit Court Judge Humes J. Franklin Jr. found 54-year-old Tory A. Garrett guilty of two misdemeanor animal cruelty counts on Wednesday.

The judge took another 10 cruelty counts under advisement.

Garrett was charged with mistreating a dozen donkeys, ponies and horses.

Authorities seized 41 horses, ponies and donkeys from his property in Waynesboro last year.

Garrett said he was targeted by a buyer who owed him money. He also said he was a victim of inaccurate statements given to authorities.
Source: Fredricksburg.com - Mar 25, 2010
Update posted on Mar 25, 2010 - 2:17PM 
A judge Friday ordered an Afton man to give up all agricultural animals, including dozens of horses and ponies seized by authorities this month for suspected malnourishment and disease.

Tory Allen Garrett, 53, repeatedly denied any wrongdoing in recent weeks and said officials would not find sickly animals on his farm, but capitulated to evidence in court.

Two ponies from Garrett's Waynesboro pasture have died this month. Most recently, a pony suffering from pneumonia and a heart murmur died in veterinary care â€" evidence enough, defense attorney Stephen Strosnider conceded, to prevent Garrett's recovery of 40 other animals seized March 17 by Waynesboro police.

Police raided Garrett's farm several days after authorities charged him with one count of animal cruelty for the death of another pony. Officials said they found horse skeletons on the property and the farm ill-equipped for the horses he kept. Garrett could face more criminal charges pending physical evaluation, said Waynesboro animal control officer Dee Price.

"He did the right thing today and relinquished ownership," said Debbie Caywood, director of the Augusta Regional Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals. "After seeing his reaction the day we were there in the field, I'm really surprised he did turn over custody today. ... I thought we were in for a battle."

The most recently deceased pony, "Hope," rated a "1" on the Henneke Body Condition Scoring System, indicating a severely underweight animal, said Assistant Commonwealth's Attorney David Ledbetter. The pony was unable to stand for most of its time at Mountain View Equine Hospital, where doctors built a custom sling to accommodate the abnormally small animal, veterinarian Scott Reiners said.

After the hearing, Garrett said he hopes the horses will find a good home.

"I don't believe the general population was [sickly]," he said.

Among the seized animals, 11 more scored a body condition of "1," and 24 scored "2" or "3," Caywood said. Many of the mares are pregnant. Caywood said the next 30 days will be "critical" in monitoring and nursing the animals back to health.

Waynesboro District Court Judge William Heatwole also ordered Garrett to cover the costs of seizure, removal, feed and medical care, which could grow to thousands of dollars, authorities said. And the judge's order ranges beyond Waynesboro.

Garrett said he has turned over all livestock to the SPCA.

Nelson County residents told The News Virginian that Garrett recently kept animals on property in Afton, but he said those animals are owned by renters.

"I do not have any other horses," he said.

Waynesboro animal control officer Dee Price said more criminal charges are possible.

"This is just the first step ... in what's to come," she said.

Garrett is scheduled to appear April 20 in Waynesboro court on the animal cruelty charge.
Source: News Virginian - March 28, 2009
Update posted on Apr 5, 2009 - 8:47AM 
An Afton man who saw 39 sickly horses and two donkeys carted away from his Waynesboro farm last week lost his rights to own the animals Friday during a petition hearing in Waynesboro General District Court.

Tory A. Garrett, 53, was arrested March 10 on one charge of misdemeanor animal cruelty after allegedly selling an emaciated horse to a buyer. The horse later died.

A second animal, a pony, seized from Garrett's farm died earlier this week, and Garrett acknowledged in court Friday that inadequate care was the culprit, according to David Ledbetter, a Waynesboro assistant prosecutor.

The health of a horse is graded from 1 to 10 through the Henneke Body Condition Scoring System. Of the 41 horses seized last week, all but one was graded a 1 or 2.

"A lot of them were 1's," Ledbetter said.

The seized animals are now under the care of the Augusta Regional SPCA. Ledbetter said Garrett will eventually have to pay for the housing, feeding and medical care of the animals. "Up to the point they're ready to be adopted," he said.

According to an affidavit to a search warrant, authorities launched an investigation targeting Garrett when the woman who bought the horse called police. The woman told police that Garrett informed her that the horse had been down for three days and had not been eating well.

"The horse had gross signs of malnutrition. Ribs, vertebrae, hips and pelvis bones were protruding and lacking any muscle mass," the affidavit stated. The woman told police she also saw several horses that appeared sick.

Police described Garrett as a buyer, seller and breeder of horses.

A hearing on the animal cruelty charge is scheduled for April 20. More charges could be pending, according to Waynesboro police.
Source: Newsleader - March 28, 2009
Update posted on Mar 30, 2009 - 3:29AM 
Authorities have seized 34 horses and ponies belonging to a Nelson County man who was charged last week with animal cruelty.

Waynesboro Animal Control officer Dee Price said many of the animals taken from the Waynesboro pasture Tuesday were severely underweight. Police loaded them in trailers for transport to an Augusta County farm.

The owner, 53-year-old Tory Allen Garrett of Afton, was charged with animal cruelty after a business associate of his took an emaciated pony to a veterinarian.

Price says Garrett could face more charges pending evaluations of the seized animals.

Garrett says a veterinarian was about to examine his horses when he happened upon the police raid. He says authorities would not find any sickly or mistreated animals.
Source: The Seattle Times - March 19, 2009
Update posted on Mar 19, 2009 - 1:24PM 

References

« Back to Search Results
« VA State Animal Cruelty Map
« More cases in Waynesboro City County, VA

Note: Classifications and other fields should not be used to determine what specific charges the suspect is facing or was convicted of - they are for research and statistical purposes only. The case report and subsequent updates outline the specific charges. Charges referenced in the original case report may be modified throughout the course of the investigation or trial, so case updates, when available, should always be considered the most accurate reflection of charges.

For more information regarding classifications and usage of this database, please visit the database notes and disclaimer.