New features are coming soon. Login with Facebook to get an early start and help us test them out!
Images for this Case
CONVICTED: Was justice served?
more information on voting
When you vote, you are voting on whether or not the punishment fit the crime, NOT on the severity of the case itself. If you feel the sentence was very weak, you would vote 1 star. If you feel the sentence was very strong, you would vote 5 stars.
Please vote honestly and realistically. These ratings will be used a a tool for many future programs, including a "People’s Choice" of best and worst sentencing, DA and judge "report cards", and more. Try to resist the temptation to vote 1 star on every case, even if you feel that 100 years in prison isn’t enough.
Case #15 Rating: 2.4 out of 5
Choked, burned and beat a dog to death, while videotaping the crime
Kansas City, KS (US)Incident Date: Friday, Jun 27, 1997
County: Wyandotte
Disposition: Convicted
Case Images: 1 files available
Defendants/Suspects:
» Jose Gutierrez
» Marcus Rodriques
» Richard Golumbski
» Lance Arsenault
Case Updates: 1 update(s) available
These 4 young men set a 6 pound Yorkshire terrier named "Scruffy" on fire, tried to break the dogs jaws, attempted to decapitate the dog and finally beat the dog to death with a shovel and videotaped themselves in the act on June 27, 1997. They told the police they did this because they were bored. The videotape was six minutes log and the boys made copies of it and distributed them to their friends.
Rodriguez and Arsenault have a history of drug use. Arsenault was on probation for possession of drug paraphernalia when he and the other 3 were charged with murdering Scruffy.
It wasn't until January 6, 1998 that someone, who received the videotape, turned the copy over to the police.
On February 9, 1998 official charges of arson and animal cruelty were brought against the four boys.
15 months later on September 11, 1998 the four were sentenced.
Marcus Rodriquez, 18, got a sentence of 2 years and 3 months in prison for arson and a year in the county jail for animal cruelty. He got a credit for 3 months for time already served and will not have to serve the additional year if he completes a parole program.
Lance Arsenault, 21, was sentenced to one year and 10 months in prison for arson and a year in the county jail for animal cruelty. He too got a credit for 3 months for time already served and will not have to serve the additional year if he completes a parole program.
Richard Golumbski, 20 and Jose Gutierrez, 17, received prison and jail terms but were place on probation for two years and are expected to receive psychiatric treatment.
Update: On August 5, 1998, Lance Arsenault now age 22, was ordered back to jail for six months for violating probation on prior drug possession charges. (The commission of the crimes against Scruffy, a felony and a misdemeanor, and failing to show proof that he had been adhering to the drug testing requirements of his probation.
Case UpdatesAlmost 10 years after a Yorkshire terrier was beaten, suffocated and set on fire, Kansas still remains one of nine states without a felony animal abuse law, KMBC's Lara Moritz reported. In May 1997, four Kansas City, Kan., men videotaped the torture and killing of the dog named Scruffy. "You're about to witness a murder," one man says on the tape. "I can still see that dog. I still have nightmares about that night," said Lee Brand, of Power for Paws. Moritz reported that Scruffy's death launched a nine-year battle in the Kansas Legislature to make animal abuse a felony offense.
"I admit I've done something senseless. I regret what I've done and I'm deeply sorry," Lance Arsenault said in a 1997 interview.
Moritz said that because Arsenault, Marcus Rodriguez, Jose Guiterrez and Richard Golubski killed Scruffy in Kansas, they spent little or no time in jail. In Kansas, a person can do anything to an animal and not be charged with a felony. The only reason Arsenault and Rodriguez spent anytime in jail is that the prosecutor got them on an arson charge because the Yorkie was set on fire. "There's no felony provision in Kansas. I assumed like many other people do that because Missouri and a majority of other states have such a provision that we did, too," Brand said. Brand is the founder of the group Power for Paws and has launched a petition, a Web site and an all-out campaign to get the word out and the Legislature in on passing a felony law. "The first time that a person commits certain crimes against animals, it will automatically be considered a felony level offense charge," Brand said. Brand, who has has counseled inmates for years, said that violent criminals often start out abusing animals. "I can tell you stories, horrendous stories especially with sex offenders and the things they have done to animals. There's a very clear link and that's why we need a felony provision," Brand said.
Last year, there was chilling testimony about Dennis Rader, known as the BTK serial killer, who first got a thrill out of strangling animals and then moved on to killing humans. Kansas legislators will look at three different proposed bills. Senate Bill No. 402 would allow people a second chance after a first offense. "To say that a person would be allowed to barbecue two different dogs, two different occasions and not have the penalty, I don't consider that an acceptable option for a bill," Brand said. Senate Bill No. 135, better known as "Scruffy's Law," would make abusing an animal a felony offense, but allow a judge to decide whether the defendant should go to jail. Senate Bill No. 408, the newest bill, would make incarceration mandatory. Since 1997, various bills have gone nowhere in the Legislature, Moritz reported. Brand hopes this time a bill will live and animals like as Scruffy won't have died in vain.
"We can't take back those years. We can't change that. All we can do now is thank the legislators for finally addressing this issue and hope that one of these bills will be passed during this legislative session.
The four men in the Scruffy case are off probation. Rodriguez and Arsenault spent less than three years in jail.
Moritz reported that "Scruffy's Law" was the topic of debate in Topeka Thursday morning. Kansas legislators listened to testimony from people for and against a felony animal abuse provision. While many want to see a felony law in place, others expressed concern that prisons were overcrowded already and that jail space should be reserved for people committing crimes against people -- not animals. Legislators will discuss the bills again. If you want to contact Kansas legislators about changing animal abuse laws, visit www.powerforpaws.com or e-mail Lee Brand at [email protected].
Kansas Senate Bill No. 402
Kansas Senate Bill No. 135
Kansas Senate Bill No. 408 | Source: KMBC News - February 2, 2006
Update posted on Mar 19, 2006 - 8:28AM |
References- The Kansas City Star
- The Associated Press
- The Topeka Capital-Journal
- The Humane Society of the United States
- ARK Online
- Animal Legal Defense Fund
- The Montel Williams Show
- Hard Copy
« More cases in Wyandotte County, KS
|
